My "Holy Grail" would be GameFan, which looks to be happening here and has happened, in lesser quality, across a few other sites. That said, I would really LOVE to have the earlier Game Informer magazines issues. I'm talking back when they were given away for free with any purchase at Funco-Land, lol. I used to have all of the earlier issues, again they pretty much gave you the current issue for free and subscriptions were something crazy, like, $3 as long as you were trading in or buying games there. They started sucking around the time the Saturn and PSX got some traction(like a lot of other mags), but up until then they were alright.
Funny story: There's an issue where they feature Shadow of "Eternal Champions: Challenge from the Dark Side" on the cover. It's either in that issue, or the one after that where they explain how that came to be. Apparently they reached out to Square and wanted to use artwork from ChronoTrigger, but the snobbish artist told them something to the effect of "My art is way too good for your crappy magazine", lol...