Yeah, Wikipedia tends to be less reliable with more obscure information. Harder to cite a source for something like this, and I should have checked that citation on the first pass. It actually has a surprisingly big article for Wario's Woods, but the citation for that bit of info wasn't the actual Nintendo Power magazine, but rather another video game review website that cited the NES review for a review of the SNES game. Based on that info, all they should have said was that Nintendo Power gave the game such and such rating, and not expounded on how Nintendo Power never reviewed the NES version of the game and ceased all coverage of NES games in March 1994 (which is just as incorrect). I've since posted about correcting the info on the talk page, haha.
Additionally, I originally thought Beauty and the Beast was the game I was thinking of, but I also found info on the net that said it was never released. That screwed things up too, because it *was* the game I was trying to think of, as NP did review it, even though it only came out in Europe. After that review, there were 2 months before and 3 months after in which NP reviewed no NES games. Also, Gail Tilden responded to reader concerns that the NES wasn't getting equal coverage, but did NOT explicitly say they were ending coverage. Then there was Wario's Woods, and that was it. When I was posting, I didn't have a chance to look them up myself, and was going on some mixed up information.
Anyway, got it all figured it out now. Going through a lot of these old issues is a trip