The more thought I give, this is probably the best console age in terms of replay value for me.
1. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles IV-- know a better brawler for SNES?
2. Secret of Mana
3. Breath of Fire I
4. Final Fantasy (II and III I hold in equal regard)
5. Street Fighter II: The World Warrior (I got the original in 3rd Grade!)
6. Knights of the Round
7. Dirt Trax FX
8. Legend of the Mystical Ninja
9. Chrono Trigger
10. Gradius III
Looking up, I see their are some really spectacular games I didn't mention.. Kudos on Pilot Wings!